This paper uses spatial statistics to test whether Tobler's First Law
applies to national culture.
Tobler's First Law of Geography states that everything is related to
everything else, but near things are more related than distant things. This
paper uses spatial statistics to test whether Tobler's First Law applies to
national culture. Are nations that are geographically close more similar in
their culture than those far apart? The results of the analysis of 26 widely
used cultural dimensions from six major studies involving between 42 and 78
countries result in a resounding yes. Indeed, some of the cultural dimensions
included are as spatially organized as temperature and rainfall. Of course, it
would be absurd to claim that geographical proximity alone can explain the
similarities and differences between national cultures. Some nations that are
half a world apart, for instance the UK and Australia, or Spain and Uruguay,
share similar cultures because of shared historical connections and large scale
immigration. Nevertheless, there are good reasons to expect a higher degree of
cultural similarity between social groups that are physically close then those
that are far apart.
First, it has been suggested that some cultural traits are adaptations to
environmental conditions. Relationships between culture and the physical
climate would tend to produce geographically organized cultural zones, because
countries that have similar climates are close together. Second, because of the
increased opportunities for communication and migration, the processes of
cultural diffusion and borrowing are likely to occur more frequently amongst
populations that are physically close together than amongst populations that
are physically far apart. This would also tend to increase the cultural
similarity between neighbouring nations. This research is the first to use
spatial autocorrelation to analyze cross-cultural data. The value of this
method is that it rather neatly side-steps Galton's Problem.